The defense argues that Nicolás Maduro remains Venezuela’s president because Delcy Rodríguez’s government has not declared the office vacant. The renewed motion follows additional charges filed by U.S. prosecutors against both defendants.
The Daily Journal.- Attorneys representing Cilia Flores, Nicolás Maduro’s wife, renewed their request on Monday for a federal court in New York to dismiss the criminal case against her, arguing that sovereign immunity protects her as a representative of a state.
Attorney Andrés Sánchez filed a new motion accompanied by a declaration and a legal memorandum, arguing that the United States recognizes the government headed by Delcy Rodríguez and that Venezuelan authorities have defended Maduro’s legitimacy and the immunity of both defendants.
Flores had previously invoked this principle alongside Maduro on September 2. However, her defense renewed the argument after U.S. prosecutors added new charges against the couple, including conspiracy to commit torture. The case also includes charges related to narcoterrorism and drug trafficking.
One of the central arguments in the new filing relies on an October 26 statement by a senior State Department official indicating that Rodríguez would have to declare a “permanent vacancy” in Venezuela’s presidency, something the defense maintains has not yet occurred.
“An office becomes vacant when someone occupies it. Therefore, according to the Executive Branch’s own account, the office for which Venezuela invokes immunity belonged to Mr. Maduro on January 3, 2026, and its holder is now absent for one reason only: he is in U.S. custody,” the document cited by the attorney states.
The defense maintains that Maduro’s detention does not terminate his immunity because Venezuela has not waived it and its constitutional framework regards the president’s absence as involuntary. “The status from which immunity derives has not ended: Venezuela has waived nothing,” Sánchez states in the filing.
The motion seeks dismissal of the case against Flores because U.S. courts cannot disregard the immunity she retains, according to her defense, as the wife of Venezuela’s head of state.
Flores’ conditions in detention
The renewed motion coincides with a New York Times report detailing the conditions Maduro and Flores face at the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn.
According to court documents the newspaper cited, Flores has lost more than 25 pounds—approximately 11 kilograms—and two teeth since her detention. Her defense has also reported that doctors prescribed nitroglycerin to treat chest pain and that she may have suffered a minor heart attack in July.
Maduro and Flores remain in custody in New York and have pleaded not guilty to the charges. The court has scheduled their trial for June 14, 2027.
With information from EFE and The New York Times
